I feel that Alablaka DOES owe people something: Treating them nicely. Everyone owes everyone else that.
If that's an obligation, it must be a mutual one. Keep in mind that we all benefit from the work the IC2 team puts into this mod, and they ask nothing from us except our patience - though they also appreciate our gratitude.
Those who demonstrate that they cannot be patient and cannot make the simple effort to conform to a simple rule, are indicating that they feel they are above the social convention of obligation - and as I said, obligation is a mutual concept.
So is virtue. Kindness is a virtue, but in order for it to have any value, it must not be squandered on those who do not value it. Alblaka has shown himself to be pretty easy-going about a great many things, and when people don't agree with him he has shown that his opinion can be changed by rational discussion. So I don't think he's out of line for this policy.
One need only look at the Minecraft mod forum to see how anything useful is lost in the noise of "OMG when is this for 1.0?" posts. Personally, if I were in his shoes, I'd be banning people who ask the same question that's already been answered on the same page as their post (often, the one directly before theirs) and people who can't be bothered to read the OP. I can be "nice", but what would be really nice is if people made a little effort instead of taking others for granted.
Quote
I personally would do a one-strike policy with this particular rule.
For most transgressions, that's understandable - but I think if people know there's no consequence to a behavior, then there's no deterrence. "Stop, or I'll say stop again!" isn't an effective warning. People know the score coming in, and if they can't even be bothered to read the rules, then they don't deserve special consideration for it.